Top 5 Refrigerator Ice Makers: Buying Guide & Review

Imagine this: You’re hosting a summer barbecue. Friends and family are gathered, the sun is shining, and you reach for an ice-cold drink. But… the ice maker is slow, jammed, or worse, completely silent. That familiar feeling of disappointment is something almost everyone with a refrigerator has experienced at some point.

Choosing the right ice maker for your fridge can feel like a maze. Do you need crescent cubes, nuggets, or gourmet ice? How fast does it need to make ice? These decisions impact your daily convenience and even your grocery budget. A poor choice can lead to constant refilling or expensive repairs down the line.

This guide cuts through the confusion. We will break down the different types of refrigerator ice makers, explain what makes them tick, and show you exactly what features matter most for your household. By the end, you will know precisely which ice maker fits your needs perfectly.

Let’s dive in and ensure your next glass of water is perfectly chilled, every single time.

Top Refrigerator Ice Maker Recommendations

No. 1
241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement, Compatible with Frigidaire Electrolux Kenmore Refrigerators, Replaces 241642511, 241642501 and 241798201 Ice Maker Assembly (Not Universal)
  • Compatible Brands: 241798224 ice maker compatible with SOME Frigidaire Electrolux Kenmore Refrigerators etc.(Not Universal)
  • Replaces Part Numbers: 241798231 ice maker replaces 241798224, 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 5303320545, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951, 5304456672, 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, AP6332951, PS12085911, 3206327 and 3206329, etc
  • Solve Problems: 241798211 ice maker stopped making ice; it's a lit noisy; ice maker does not turn off
  • Easy Installation: 241642511 ice maker is equipped with a new built-in wiring harness. Just unplug the power plug and install the new device. Install the ice maker by yourself and quickly get your refrigerator back to work
  • Please Note: Before buying, please confirm whether it is suitable for your refrigerator model. If you can't find it, please let us know and we can check it for you
No. 2
KITCHEN BASICS 101: 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669
  • 【DESCRIPTION】Ice maker features 8 cubs per cycle and an automatic shut-off arm. You may need to replace yours if there is no ice production, debris in the ice, ice not emptying from the ice maker, leaking water.
  • 【241798224 ICE MAKER REPLACES】241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 3206327, 3206329, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951 B011P1OODQ, 5304456672. 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12364147
  • 【COMPATIBLE WITH ELECTROLUX】E23CS75DSS9 E23CS75DSSC E23CS75DSSE E23CS75DSSF E23CS75DSSG E23CS75DSSH E23CS78EPS2 E23CS78EPS3 E23CS78EPS4 E23CS78ESS2 E23CS78GPS1 E23CS78GPS2 E23CS78GPS3 E23CS78GPS4 E23CS78GSS1 E23CS78GSS2 E23CS78GSS3 E23CS78GSS4 E23CS78HPS0 E23CS78HPS1 E23CS78HPS2 E23CS78HPS3 E23CS78HPS5 E23CS78HPS6 E23CS78HPS7 E23CS78HSS0 E23CS78HSS1 E23CS78HSS2 E23CS78HSS3 E23CS78HSS4 E23CS78HSS5 E32AF75FPS0 E32AF75FPS1 E32AF75FPS2 E32AF75FPS3 E32AF75FPS4 E32AF75FPS5 E32AF75FPS6 E32AF75GTT0
  • 【COMPATIBLE WITH FRIGIDAIRE】FRS6LR5EB3 FRS6LR5EM2 FRS26ZNHB0 FRS26H5ASBA FRS6R5ESB4 FRS26ZRFW3 FRS26RLECS0 FRS26ZSHB0 FRS26H5ASB4 FRS26R4CB1 FRS26H5ASB8 FRS26LF7DS7 FRS26R2AW6 PLHS269ZCB4 FRS6LR5EB6 FRS26R4AW5 FRS6LR5EM8 FRS26ZRGB8 FRS26R4CW0 FRT18LN5BW0 FRS26H5ASB9 FRS6LR5EW6 FRS23H5ASB8 FRS26R2AWA FRS26R4CB3 PLHS269ZCB2 FRS26ZRGWA FRS26R2AWG FRS26R4CW1 FRS26RLECSG FRS6LR5EW3 FRS6R5ESB6 FRS26RLECS2 FRS26ZNHW0 FRS26LH5DS2 FRS26R4AW6 FRS26R2AW8 FRS26ZRGB0 FRS26F5AW0 FRS26R4AW1 FRS24WSCB1
  • 【PRODUCT DIMENSIONS】4.5 x 4.75 x 11.3"
No. 3
Bare Ice Maker Fits Whirlpool WPW10190965 D7824706Q 4317943 W10190965 1129313
  • IT FROM XUQCAH MATERIAL AND FOIMOJSK PARTMENT AND Thurder LOVER
No. 4
Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker (Replaces W10190965, W11381372) Genuine Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM + FSP) Part
  • The WPW10190965 is a genuine OEM Whirlpool Ice Maker Assembly which is manufactured to exact specifications with high quality materials; ensuring a long lasting perfect fit into the appliance it was manufactured for.
  • The Whirlpool WPW10190965 Refrigerator Ice Maker (Replaces W10190965, W11381372) fits SOME models from the following brands of refrigerator: Whirlpool, Kenmore, Amana, Maytag.
  • The Whirlpool WPW10190965 receives water from the water inlet valve and then holds the water in the ice mold until the water freezes solid; it then automatically ejects the ice and refills to continue the process until the ice storage bin is full
  • The Whirlpool WPW10190965 is a new part that replaces part numbers: W10122506, W10122507, W10122510, W10190965, W10190966, W10190969, W10270037, W11381372, WPW10190965VP
  • Includes The Ice Mold, Ice Maker Body And The Control Device. The Ice Shut-Off Arm and the Front Cover are NOT included; Use the parts from the old Ice Maker or order shut-off arm and front cover separately If needed.
No. 5
KITCHEN BASICS 101 WR30X10093 Ice Maker Kit Replacement for GE Refrigerators TFX26KRDAWW GSH25SGPCSS GSS20IEMBCC PSS26SGRBSS TFX25JRYDWW GSL22JFTABS HSS25GFPDWW TFH24PRSBWW GSS20IETAWW HSS25GFPEWW
  • [ WR30X10093 Replaces ] AP4345120, WR29X160, WR29X5181, WR29X157, WR29X10001, WR29X10080, WR29X185, WR29X5162, WR30X10102, 1399596, AH1993870, EA1993870, PS1993870, WR29X0157, WR29X0158, WR29X0160, WR29X0185, WR29X0191, WR29X20949, WR29X27993, WR30M0149, WR30M0153, WR30X0138, WR30X0147, WR30X0148, WR30X0159, WR30X0169, WR30X0199, WR30X0203, WR30X0213, WR30X0214, WR30X0238, WR30X0241, WR30X0282, WR30X0283, WR30X0289, WR30X0290, WR30X0304, WR30X0306, WR30X0307, WR30X0315, WR30X0318, WR30X0320
  • WR30X0327, WR30X0328, WR30X0329, WR30X10058, WR30X10061, WR30X10082, WR30X10109, WR30X10111, WR30X10139, WR30X27952, WR30X28705, WR30X29421
  • [ Package Includes ] Ice maker, wire adapter, power cords, end mounted fill cups, fill tube, instruction sheet. Compatible with GE, General Electric, Hotpoint, Kenmore, Sears, RCA refrigerators, side by side. Fixes the following symptoms, Ice maker won't make ice, won't dispense ice, leaks
  • [ Risk free shopping ] Superior quality you can trust! This SupplyEdge product is UL/CSA approved to assure safe operation and long life. Warr anty, this part by SupplyEdge come with a 1 year, no questions asked, no hassle warra nty.
  • [ Compatible with GE ] GSS20IEMBWW HSS25GFPAWW GSL25JFPABS HSS25IFMDWW GSH25JSTASS HSS25GFPJWW GSS25JFMBWW GSS25JFMCWW GSS20IEMDWW GSS25JFMDWW GSH25JSRFSS PSS26SGPASS GSL25JFTABS PSS25SGNABS TFX20JRBKWW HSS25GFPHWW HSS25IFMBWW TFH24PRSMWW GSS22JFMCWW GSS25SGMDBS PFS22SISBSS GSL25IFRFBS GSL25JFPEBS HSS25IFMCWW TFX26KPDAWW GSS25SGMCBS GSS20IEPAWW HSM25GFTASA HSS25GFTAWW GSS20IEPHWW TFX26ZPDAWW GSS22SGMCBS GSS22SGMDBS PSS25MGNAWW GSH25SGPASS GSL25JFPHBS GSL25JFPDBS TPS24BPDABS PSS27SGNABS
No. 6
Endurance Pro 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement for Electrolux Frigidaire Kenmore Sears Refrigerator 241642511 241798201 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669
  • This OEM Ice maker features 8 cubs per cycle and an automatic shut-off arm. You may need to replace yours if there is no ice production, debris in the ice, ice not emptying from the ice maker, leaking water. 115V, 60HZ, 1.6 AMPS
  • 241798224 Frigidaire ICE MAKER REPLACEsS: 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241642503A, 241798211, 241798231, 241642511, 241798209, 3206327, 3206329, 5303320545, 5304445222, 5304456669, PS10057209, AP6332951 B011P1OODQ, 5304456672. 241798220, 75304445222, 75304456669, 75304456671, 75304456672, 4591526, PS12364147
  • COMPATIBLE WITH ELECTROLUX: E23CS75DSS9 E23CS75DSSC E23CS75DSSE E23CS75DSSF E23CS75DSSG E23CS75DSSH E23CS78EPS2 E23CS78EPS3 E23CS78EPS4 E23CS78ESS2 E23CS78GPS1 E23CS78GPS2 E23CS78GPS3 E23CS78GPS4 E23CS78GSS1 E23CS78GSS2 E23CS78GSS3 E23CS78GSS4 E23CS78HPS0 E23CS78HPS1 E23CS78HPS2 E23CS78HPS3 E23CS78HPS5 E23CS78HPS6 E23CS78HPS7 E23CS78HSS0 E23CS78HSS1 E23CS78HSS2 E23CS78HSS3 E23CS78HSS4 E23CS78HSS5 E32AF75FPS0 E32AF75FPS1 E32AF75FPS2 E32AF75FPS3 E32AF75FPS4 E32AF75FPS5 E32AF75FPS6 E32AF75GTT0
  • COMPATIBLE WITH FRIGIDAIRE: FRS6LR5EB3 FRS6LR5EM2 FRS26ZNHB0 FRS26H5ASBA FRS6R5ESB4 FRS26ZRFW3 FRS26RLECS0 FRS26ZSHB0 FRS26H5ASB4 FRS26R4CB1 FRS26H5ASB8 FRS26LF7DS7 FRS26R2AW6 PLHS269ZCB4 FRS6LR5EB6 FRS26R4AW5 FRS6LR5EM8 FRS26ZRGB8 FRS26R4CW0 FRT18LN5BW0 FRS26H5ASB9 FRS6LR5EW6 FRS23H5ASB8 FRS26R2AWA FRS26R4CB3 PLHS269ZCB2 FRS26ZRGWA FRS26R2AWG FRS26R4CW1 FRS26RLECSG FRS6LR5EW3 FRS6R5ESB6 FRS26RLECS2 FRS26ZNHW0 FRS26LH5DS2 FRS26R4AW6 FRS26R2AW8 FRS26ZRGB0 FRS26F5AW0 FRS26R4AW1 FRS24WSCB1
  • This Endurance Pro part by Innovative Supply is UL/CSA approved to assure safe operation and long life and comes with a 1 year, no questions asked, no hassle warr anty.
No. 7
BLACK+DECKER 16 Cu. Ft. French Door Refrigerator with Built-in Ice Maker, Full Size Refrigerator with Bottom Mount Freezer Drawer, Frost Free, ENERGY STAR certified, BRF1600GIMB, Black
  • Modern French Door Style: French Door fridge with bottom freezer refrigerator adds style and modern elegance to any kitchen décor. Offers full access to contents and is perfect for any home kitchen
  • Spacious Organization: With full-width 11.15 cu. ft. fridge and 5.06 cu. ft. total freezer capacity, our French door fridge with freezer offers ample storage space and options for all your essentials
  • Bottom Freezer with Ice Machine: Included ice maker with built-in sensor produces as much as 3.5 lbs. of ice per day, depending on the temperature of the freezer and other operating conditions
  • Digital Temperature Control: Our digital thermostat easily controls each compartment for precise climate control. Set the perfect cooling levels for both the refrigerator and freezer sections
  • Energy Star Certified: High performance and energy efficient compressor creates less heat and maximizes energy and dollar savings without sacrificing the features you want
No. 8
Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit for Refrigerators, White
  • Quality Craftsmanship: The Frigidaire IM116000 Ice Maker Assembly Kit is designed and engineered by Frigidaire to exact specifications, which, unlike non-genuine parts, ensures optimal performance for your appliance
  • Tools Required: To install this item, you'll need the following: 1/4" nut driver, adjustable wrench, gloves, safety glasses
  • Repair Skill Level: Experienced Repair Person | For optimal results, it's recommended that someone with specialized training install this part
  • Compatibility: Check the appliance user manual to verify that this part is compatible with your appliance before purchasing
  • Frigidaire Assurance: Confidently repair your appliance when you choose genuine Frigidaire parts

Your Guide to Picking the Best Refrigerator Ice Maker

Buying a new refrigerator or just replacing a broken ice maker can feel tricky. You want ice, and you want it fast! This guide helps you pick the right ice maker for your kitchen needs.

Key Features to Look For

When shopping, look closely at what the ice maker can actually do. These features make your life easier.

  • **Ice Production Rate:** How much ice does it make in 24 hours? If you host big parties, you need a fast maker. Small families can use slower models.
  • **Ice Storage Capacity:** This is how much ice the bin holds. A bigger bin means you refill the maker less often.
  • **Ice Type:** Do you want crescent-shaped cubes, or do you prefer crushed ice? Some machines make both.
  • **Smart Features/Controls:** Some modern ice makers have sensors that stop production when the bin is full. Look for easy-to-read controls.
  • **Filter System:** Good ice makers often include a water filter. This keeps your ice tasting fresh and clean.
Important Materials Matter

The parts inside the ice maker must handle cold temperatures and constant use. Quality materials last longer.

Most good ice makers use strong plastic for the housing and the ice mold. Metal components, especially in the motor and water inlet valve, ensure durability. Avoid cheap, brittle plastics that crack easily when they get cold. Check reviews to see if users report common plastic failures.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Quality isn’t just about brand name; it’s about how the machine is built and how you use it.

What Makes Ice Makers Better?
  • **Reliable Water Supply:** A steady flow of clean water helps the maker work consistently.
  • **Good Insulation:** Better insulation keeps the ice frozen longer, even if the refrigerator door opens a lot.
  • **Self-Cleaning Cycles:** Some high-end models clean themselves, which reduces mold buildup and improves taste.
What Can Harm Your Ice Maker?
  • **Water Quality Issues:** Hard water (water with lots of minerals) can clog the water lines and the fill tube. This slows down ice production significantly.
  • **Frequent Power Fluctuations:** Sudden power cuts can mess up the internal electronics.
  • **Overfilling:** Forcing ice into a full bin can damage the ejector mechanism.

User Experience and Use Cases

Think about how you use ice every day. This helps determine the size and speed you need.

If you live alone and drink iced tea occasionally, a small, slow ice maker works fine. However, if you have teenagers who constantly fill sports bottles, you need a high-capacity model. People who use crushed ice often should make sure the dispenser mechanism is strong. Remember, if the ice maker is in the freezer door, it saves shelf space inside the fridge, which is great for storing large items.

10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Refrigerator Ice Makers

Q: How often should I clean my ice maker?

A: You should clean the ice bin and the surrounding area every three to six months. This prevents odors and buildup.

Q: Can I install an ice maker if my fridge didn’t come with one?

A: Sometimes, yes, but it is complicated. You need the correct water line hookup and often specific replacement parts designed for that refrigerator model.

Q: Why is my ice maker suddenly slow?

A: Usually, a slow maker means the water inlet valve is getting clogged, or the water temperature entering the fridge is too warm.

Q: What is the lifespan of a typical refrigerator ice maker?

A: With regular maintenance, most good ice makers last between 7 and 15 years. They often last as long as the refrigerator itself.

Q: Does the ice maker use a lot of electricity?

A: No, they use very little electricity overall. Most of the power goes to the small motor that turns the ice ejector.

Q: What does it mean if the ice is small or misshapen?

A: This usually signals that the freezer temperature is too warm, or the water isn’t freezing completely before it falls into the bin.

Q: Should I turn off the ice maker when I go on vacation?

A: Yes, if you are gone for a long time, turn it off. This saves energy and prevents the machine from making ice that might melt and refreeze into one big block.

Q: My ice tastes funny. Is the filter to blame?

A: Most likely, yes. Water filters need replacing every six months. If you skip this, the filter stops cleaning the water, and the ice tastes bad.

Q: What is the difference between in-door and in-freezer ice makers?

A: In-door models dispense ice through the door, which is convenient. In-freezer models sit inside the freezer compartment and usually hold more ice.

Q: Can I use regular tap water if my water tastes fine?

A: Yes, you can, but using filtered water always results in clearer, better-tasting ice and keeps the machine running smoother.